Discovering Resilience: A Deep Dive into "Soul on Fire"
In 2011, director Sean McNamara, known for his work with Disney and Nickelodeon, scored a sleeper hit with the inspirational biopic "Soul Surfer." This film, which follows the real-life story of Hawaiian surfer Bethany Hamilton as she triumphs over adversity after losing an arm to a shark attack, became a beloved choice for fans of faith-based entertainment. After a few less successful projects, including last year’s "Reagan," McNamara returns to familiar territory with his latest film, "Soul on Fire."
This new film is inspired by John O’Leary’s 2016 memoir "On Fire," and it tells the story of a young man grappling with the aftermath of a near-fatal accident. Like "Soul Surfer," "Soul on Fire" aims to resonate with viewers who appreciate family-friendly narratives filled with positive messages about overcoming challenges. However, while Hamilton’s story was deeply rooted in the world of professional surfing, O’Leary’s journey revolves around his love for baseball, which may not be as compelling in comparison.
Despite some shortcomings, "Soul on Fire" is well-crafted and effectively captures themes of conflict and bravery. However, it does occasionally feel drawn out, with a runtime nearing two hours. The screenplay by Gregory Poirier keeps the audience engaged by employing a non-linear narrative. The film opens with adult O’Leary, portrayed by Joel Courtney, who is now working in home construction. When asked to speak to a Girl Scout troop about his past, he reflects back on the traumatic events that shaped his life.
At the age of nine, young John (played by James McCracken) was a typical baseball-loving boy living in suburban St. Louis in 1987. One fateful day, inspired by older kids playing with gasoline and matches, he attempts a dangerous experiment that leads to a catastrophic explosion, severely injuring himself and covering 100% of his body in burns. Miraculously, he survives, thanks in large part to the unwavering support of his family, a dedicated male nurse (DeVon Franklin), and local sportscaster Jack Buck (played by William H. Macy), who takes a special interest in him.
After spending five months in the hospital, John faces significant life adjustments, including learning to use prosthetic hands after losing several fingers. Despite his challenges, he becomes a well-liked figure in college, known for his party spirit. Yet, his self-confidence remains fragile. He develops a close friendship with fellow student Beth (Masey McLain) but struggles with shyness when it comes to asking her out. As John’s journey continues, he overcomes additional hurdles to become a professional public speaker, but he confesses to his father, who is battling Parkinson’s disease, that he often feels like a “fraud” and an “emotional coward.”
While Courtney’s portrayal of John O’Leary is endearing, the character lacks the depth necessary to fully convey his internal struggles. The supporting cast, though talented, sometimes feels one-dimensional, which detracts from the film’s overall impact. The screenplay and direction maintain a surface-level approach, often punctuated by an upbeat soundtrack featuring nostalgic hits from artists like Smash Mouth, Neil Diamond, and Journey, along with contemporary Christian music. Unfortunately, the original score by Mark Isham falls flat and lacks inspiration.
The film aims to inspire, but its simplistic narrative may not resonate with everyone. As the credits roll, glimpses of the real John O’Leary make "Soul on Fire" feel somewhat like an extended advertisement for his books and speaking engagements. Additionally, the film’s portrayal of triumph often includes cheering crowds, which may contradict its focus on personal faith and resilience, creating a somewhat unrealistic picture of piety and selflessness.
Overall, "Soul on Fire" is a competent feel-good film that delivers an uplifting message for viewers who enjoy familiar storytelling. However, its generic execution may not persuade those seeking a deeper exploration of its themes. If you’re in the mood for an inspiring true story that emphasizes resilience and hope, "Soul on Fire" could be a worthwhile watch, even if it doesn’t break new ground in the genre.
